Hate Crime For Rutgers Outers?

While we wait to see if New Jersey prosecutors will pursue hate crime enhancements against Dharun Ravi and Molly Wei in connection with the outing of Rutgers student Tyler Clementi, is there anyone out there in the community who may want to see this with a more positive spin?

Just think, after years of being saddled with that “model minority” stereotype we can now breathe a sigh of relief. There on the front pages we have living examples of college-age Asian Americans behaving badly.

See, we really are more well-rounded than that standard issue Asian geek cum nerd image. We are capable of so much less.

Doesn’t that make you feel better? So much for uplift.

That leaves us with the only positive for Ravi and Wei: once all the facts are in, I see it unlikely that what they are alleged to have done constitutes a bias crime.

At this point, Ravi and Wei face charges based on the New Jersey law prohibiting the transmitting of sexual images and content without a person’s consent. Maximum prison term? Five years. Likely they’ll get less. Want an enhancement? Take away internet, cell phones and gadgets. Ouch.

Now that’s harsh, dude.

Still see it as a bullying/bias crime? Sure, what happened in the aftermath, Clementi’s suicide is tragic. But put the basic facts to a simple test: Clementi was gay, but would Ravi and Wei do what they did to a straight roommate? In place of Tyler Clementi, insert one Joe Jock- BMOC, who gets set up with a tranny or a prostitute or an inflatable doll. (You make the call.)

You think Ravi and Wei would have the webcam on? Of course they would, because the only bias they have is for something more interesting than their own boring lives. In the end, what motivated the Rutgers Deux isn’t the gayness, the sexiness, or anything remotely human.

These kids aren’t really voyeurs or sex deviants. Nor are they homophobes. They’re technophiliacs. I’m coining the term to define people with an irrational love of technology, where the love of technology is greater than the love of humanity. Where kindness is lost and never a consideration. The only thing that matters: Hey, I can do THAT with THIS GADGET? That IS SOOOO cool.

Call it “Plug and Play” morality.

When you’re cut off from human feelings, cool is all you need. Ravi and Wei were both way cool, sadly.

The comic Flip Wilson used to parade in drag as Geraldine, and proclaim, “The devil made me do it.” With Plug and Play values, it’s “the technology made me do it.” That’s not a hate crime. That’s just a crime crime.

So no hate crime enhancements. But if I were judge and jury, I’d just take away all their toys. Cell phones. Webcams. Slingboxes. For life.

I’d give them typewriters to do their term papers. Rolls of quarters for pay phones. 8-track tapes for their music. I’d strip them of their Kindles. Then throw the book at them.

Image by AALDEF

Emil Guillermo is an independent journalist/commentator. Updates at Follow Emil on Twitter, and like his Facebook page.

The views expressed in his blog do not necessarily represent AALDEF’s views or policies.

Read Emil's full bio →