When Joyce Xi graduates from college next week, I hope the celebratory pride and
joy she and her family experience will be so tremendous, it will blast away the
cloud of suspicion and shame that has hovered over them the last year, once and
That’s always the hope when you come to a “good” life event.
The family has had to endure a “bad” one that began May 21, 2015.
That’s when the world changed for Joyce’s father, Dr. Xiaoxing Xi, and the
entire Xi family.
It was the year of being falsely accused of spying.
If you saw Dr. Xi on “60
then you saw him pantomime exactly what happened nearly a year ago when the
F.B.I. visited the family’s suburban Philadelphia home. With guns drawn, agents
vigorously knocked on the front door, then cuffed and arrested the physicist as
his family stood by in disbelief.
Dr. Xi, a naturalized Chinese American citizen, and, at the time, head of the
physics department at Temple University, was accused of spying for China.
And even though the charges were
last September, the emotional pain of the experience hasn’t dissipated at all.
“Yeah, it’s been really hard on everybody,” Joyce Xi told me on the phone. “You
only see the headlines that the case was brought, the charges were dropped, and
all those things,every single day, worrying about…80 years in prison and a
million dollar fine. Being under surveillance and things like that. That’s the
part that people don’t see. And that just doesn’t go away.”
As I talked to Joyce, I couldn’t help think of Wen Ho Lee, the Taiwanese
American who worked at Los Alamos Laboratories and was accused of transferring
nuclear secrets to China in 1999, and his daughter Alberta.
Lee was arrested, detained for nine months, sometimes in solitary confinement.
But then the government’s espionage case fell apart, and _The New York Times_,
which had led the media drumbeat against Lee, published a semi-mea culpa.
It wasn’t quite an apology for racial profiling, but it was a soft admission of
the Times‘ reporting flaws, an over-reliance on government sources, and the
harsh, accusatory tone it used in stories about Lee.
One paragraph in that editors’ note,
in particular, has always stuck in my mind. It’s where the paper admitted, “We
never prepared a full-scale profile of Dr. Lee, which might have humanized him
and provided some balance.”
I remembered that line when I talked to Joyce Xi the other day.
So here’s a humanizing fact.
To pass the time, Joyce said she and her father like to play the popular board
game, “Settlers of Catan.”
Who wins? She says she does.
But in the strategy game, they both share a scientific approach to things.
Though she’s more chemistry than physics, she admits to taking after her father.
“I’m an Asian scientist,” she tells me. “He’s always been into science,
research, and ideas. So yeah, I grew up around that. Science is his life.”
Joyce’s too. And that’s been the troubling thing about the facts in her father’s
“It’s hard to reconcile,” she said. “It shouldn’t be that way. The facts should
speak for themselves. But that’s not what happened.”
She said she’s not sure why the case was even brought forward.
“My dad was prosecuted for sharing a product called the pocket heater with
entities in China,” Joyce said. “My dad never shared the pocket heater with
China. They should not have brought up the case.”
She wonders why the government didn’t consult an independent scientific expert
who actually understood the science before they prosecuted her father.
But we’re not dealing with science here, just politics.
Members of Congress
already called for an investigation and an apology last year, when the charges
against Xi and another Chinese American scientist, Sherry Chen,
were dropped. Although the Justice Department dropped the charges against Chen,
her employer, the National Weather Service, fired her. In response, Chen has
since filed a discrimination complaint.
But nothing seems to have changed to prevent more racial profiling against Asian
American scientists. Earlier this year, the Justice Department did issue a
to its prosecutors that all future national security cases like Xi’s will be
directed by more experienced officials in Washington.
Community activists don’t think that’s enough to protect future innocent people.
And it’s not good enough for those who’ve been through the wringer, like Joyce
She’s leading a public
drive calling for an independent investigation and a formal apology for her
father and other Asian Americans who have been wrongly accused.
“The government has not substantively responded to my father’s case or been held
responsible for it,” she said. “This is something that has shaken our whole
family, and my dad should not have been prosecuted to begin with.”
“So, it’s something that we’ll carry with us forever,” she added. “It’s not just
going to go away. And we hope this never has to happen to anybody ever again.”