‘Last Fable Day’? Asian Americans looking for a first one, as “Fresh Off the Boat” Snubbed for Emmy Awards
Randall Park has had such a big year as the star of “The Interview” and as the
comedic anchor of “Fresh Off the Boat.” He even won a V3con
award from the
Asian American Journalists Association in Los Angeles this year for
But if he wants a shot at an Emmy, he’d better talk to Easter Xua.
There’s no success perm for Randall this year. But Xua may consider finally
getting one. Until then, Randall will have to go straight.
As far as my eyes can tell, as I
gleaned the list, Xua has to be the most honored Asian American among the
nominees for the 2015 Primetime Emmy Awards.
He may even be the most nominated Asian American ever.
How many Asian Americans have won seven Emmys and been nominated 36 times?
But you have to go practically to the bottom of the long list of categories and
nominees to find his name.
Xua is a camera operator, Cinematographers Union Local 600, and he’s nominated
for no fewer than three Emmys this year.
It’s not greed. He’s just talented and in demand.
The first of this year’s nominations is for Outstanding Technical Direction,
Camerawork, Video Control For A Series. Xua is nominated for “Dancing with the
Stars,” episode 2009 (I believe it’s the semi-finals).
Xua was on camera to catch every last dip and spin.
It’s a tough category though. He’s up against Fred Shimizu, a two-time winner
and 11-time nominee, who runs a camera on the “Late Show with David Letterman.”
(Show 4214 got nominated, which, of course, was so much better than Show 4213).
And then there’s Terrance Ho, video control for “The Voice” Episode 718B. It
takes some doing to synchronize all those spinning coach seats to get every last
white tooth on camera.
For Ho, it’s two nominations this year, eight overall in his career, and he’s
still looking for his first win.
And just to prove what an incestuous community Hollywood is, Ho is nominated for
video control for the Oscars in the Outstanding Technical Direction, Camerawork,
Video Control for a Limited Series, Movie Or A Special. And that show also
includes Xua on camera (his second nomination for the year).
Xua adds a third nomination for camerawork for the “Kennedy Center Honors” in
the same category.
But wait, like the Ginsu knife, there’s more!
Add one, maybe two more names. The 68th Annual Tony Awards got nominated in that
very category, and lo and behold, there’s Ka-Lai Wong, Senior Video Control, and
Ernie Jew, on camera. Jew, I shall presume, is not Jewish but Asian American.
And that’s where Asian Americans tend to show up in television. We’re in deep.
Behind the scenes.
Go up the list of nominees and you’ll find Ai Nakata of “Mad Men” for
Outstanding Hairstyling for a Single-Camera Series. Two nominations for Robert
Lopez for Outstanding Original Music and Lyrics.
I’m sorry for the Filipinos with Spanish surnames (it’s the same problem in
political polling) or married, non-hyphenated Asians who now are undetectably
Asian in print, so I may have missed one or two of you. My apologies.
But the Asian names that were more obvious are sprinkled all throughout the list
Garson Yu and Synderela Peng (great name) for Outstanding Main Titles for HBO’s
Kodai Yoshizawa for “The Knick,” and Outstanding Prosthetic Makeup For a Series,
Lmited Series, Movie or Special. Prosthetic? Did he fix all the noses and busts?
Makeup artist Mi Young for HBO’s “Bessie” was in the non-prosthetic category.
Also nominated were Joseph Tsai for sound editing in “The Walking Dead” and
visual effects artists Keith Hamakawa for “The Flash,” Tracy Takahashi for
“Marvel’s Agents of S.H.I.EL.D,” and Tommy Tran for “American Horror Story.”
And as you move up the list to picture editing you find Luyen Vu for “American
Crime.” And Billy Song, editor for the his work on “Inside Amy Schumer.”
It’s ironic, of course, because many Asian American actors, both male and female
are looking for their first “Fable Day.”
When you’re limited to working behind the scenes, at least in Schumer terms, you
have zero “fable days.”
And when we’re bottom heavy on the list of nominees, in the crafts, stereotypes
develop. And star turns aren’t our turns.
This year, I thought Randall Park and Constance Wu would have a shot to get some
“Fresh Off the Boat” had a chance for Best Comedy. I thought the pilot had great
promise, but the weekly episodes rarely surpassed that level. Maybe when you’re
not on cable like many of the other nominees, the real edge of FOTB gets lost
and it all seems homogenized. Not that the elements weren’t there. It’s just in
execution, one wonders how much edgier and funnier the show would have been if
it were more representative of Eddie Huang’s urban hybrid/”black-ish” Asian
perspective–and on cable?
Given the restraints, I like the show better when it’s focused on Wu and Park in
a modern Asian American “Father Knows Best.” I like it least when it aims to be
the Asian American “Leave it to Beaver.”
But look at the other series that got nominated. Only “Modern Family” and “Parks
and Rec” were network shows. I think “P&R” is funny, but academy voters seemed
to be willing to award it for the grand finale. “Modern Family” has become a
staple. But aside from me wanting to look at Julie Bowen (nominated just as
supporting actress, and not lead actress), the show’s gotten a tad stale.
All the other shows nominated have a cable edge that make “FOTB” seem bland.
“Louie” is my favorite and even featured an Asian American shopkeeper in one
episode. But it’s barely a comedy, more like an art film masquerading as sitcom.
“FOTB” has a built-in edge as the only prime-time sitcom with a window into the
Asian American soul. But it seems more into showing off our universality, hence
the blandness. More subtitled humor to differentiate from the rest, please.
For me, Randall and Constance have become the real reason to watch. So I’m
disappointed that Emmy nominators couldn’t squeeze them in the supporting
category. It’s a crowded field, but Randall and Constance did some breakthrough
work this year.
It may be enough that the show got a second season. But I hope the show takes a
few more risks while it still has the chance. If it does, there’s no reason why
it can’t break through and garner Emmy gold next year.
If it doesn’t, well, at least we still have our 36-time nominee Easter Xua.
Emil Guillermo is an independent journalist/commentator. Updates at www.amok.com. Follow Emil on Twitter, and like his Facebook page. The views expressed in his blog do not necessarily represent AALDEF’s views or policies.