In a Trump era, Fred Korematsu matters more today than ever
January 30th is the birthday of a true Asian American hero, Fred Korematsu.
Since 2011, it’s been a designated holiday in California and a few other states.
It doesn’t get you a day off. In fact, it’s a day that reminds you to fight.
It’s a a day set aside specifically to remind us that when it comes to civil
rights and individual liberties, America can never afford to take even one day
It was a bit of karmic grace that the Monday after the most severe of the Trump
administration’s executive orders to date–the travel ban against refugees and
immigrants from seven Muslim-majority nations–all of us, not just Asian
Americans, and partially thanks to Google, find ourselves recalling Korematsu’s
As a young Californian in Oakland, Korematsu was the one who said no to the
incarceration of Japanese Americans during World War II.
He stood up, resisted, and paid the price in 1942.
When he was arrested for his principled stand, the ACLU took his case all the
way to the U.S. Supreme Court. The government upheld his conviction and the
internment of Japanese Americans, citing “military necessity.”
Are you beginning to hear history’s echoes?
Critics have said the Court seemed unwilling to go against the government and
President Roosevelt, although three justices dissented.
Here’s the crazy thing.
To this day, that 1944 decision still stands.
Korematsu lost his constitutional challenge and spent time in an internment
camp. But he also found that not only was he shunned by general society and his
country at war, he was also shunned by other Japanese Americans in camp who
believed he should have shut up and cooperated.
But vindication ultimately would come to Korematsu four decades later.
In 1983, Prof. Peter Irons, a legal historian, discovered government memos that
were withheld from the Supreme Court in 1944. The documents revealed an internal
struggle within the government on how to present the case. Would it proceed with
the Army’s contention that Japanese Americans were a threat to national
security? Or would it also present information from the FBI and other military
intelligence that contradicted the Army?
The Army’s perspective prevailed. But Irons said a statement in one military
document continued to haunt and fuel the protest. It read: “We are telling lies
to the Supreme Court. We have an obligation to tell the truth.”
Lies? You mean “alternate facts”?
The discovery of the suppressed information enabled a group of attorneys, mostly
young Japanese Americans, to reopen the case and overturn Korematsu’s conviction
in 1983 in a federal district court in San Francisco.
There was one catch.
Because the government declined to appeal, the 1944 Supreme Court decision still
Korematsu’s legal team couldn’t directly challenge the high court’s opinion.
“We were stuck at the district court level,” said lead attorney Dale Minami.
“But we did undercut the factual and legal basis for what the Supreme Court
When I talked to Minami a few years ago, it was during the Obama years. He told
me it would be ignorant for anyone to use Korematsu as a precedent today for
the wholesale imprisonment of people because of their race.
What he didn’t imagine then was the possibility of Donald J. Trump as the 45th
president of the United States.
When Sen. Chuck Schumer called Trump’s travel ban “un-American and
mean-spirited,” and even shed a tear for the refugees blocked by the executive
order, Trump mocked him by saying, “Who was his acting coach?”
Now with his SCOTUS pick to be announced this week, Trump appears like some
tyrannical “man in full.”
We must all remember Korematsu.
Democracy requires our voices now.
FROM KOREMATSU TO TODAY’S CHAOS
On Fox News, Rudy Giuliani admitted that Trump told him he wanted a Muslim ban
and asked him how to do it legally.
The hastily-drafted and semi-secretive executive order on the “travel ban” is a
result of the Trump administration’s toxic twins, the Breitbarter Stephen Bannon
and Stephen Miller.
There is no specific mention of “Muslim,” but the executive order restricts
nationals from seven Muslim-majority countries: Iraq, Iran, Yemen, Somalia,
Sudan, Libya, and Syria.
Maybe Trump doesn’t have plans for hotels there.
None of the seven countries have yielded any people responsible for the most
notorious terror attacks in America. Oddly, Saudi Arabia, Pakistan, Egypt, and
the United Arab Emirates were left off the list.
So we have a semi-partial, non-specific Muslim ban that’s just a little bit
But the order does come with Trump’s stated preference among “religious
minorities” for the immigration of Christians over Muslims.
That’s clearly unconstitutional.
Asian Americans know what it’s like to be singled out and banned from
immigration. From the Chinese Exclusion Act of 1882, to the Japanese and the
“Gentleman’s Agreement” in 1907, to the Filipinos in 1934 and the
Tydings-McDuffie Act, Asians have been the target of America’s xenophobia.
It wasn’t until President Johnson signed the Immigration and Nationality Act of
1965, when Congress banned racist country-specific quotas, that Asian
immigration was able to flourish.
If you forgot that, maybe you remembered this weekend when the echoes of history
became a call to action.
If you were protesting at airports or federal buildings across the nation,
Ahmed Ali wishes he could have been with you.
Because of the vague executive order and haphazard communications to those
implementing it on the front lines, hundreds of people were detained for hours
at American airports over the weekend.
But Ali, 39, a Yemeni American who lives near me in California’s Central Valley,
wasn’t at LAX or SFO.
If Trump were waging a preemptive strike against the people he believes are
so-called “bad Muslims,” the only ones affected by the executive order seem to
be real innocents like Ali.
He was stuck in Djibouti with his 12-year-old daughter at an airport. Officials
blocked them from a scheduled Ethiopian Airlines flight that would take them
back home to the U.S.
“The USA is supposed to be the example of freedom,” Ali told the newspaper, the
Los Banos Enterprise. “Now, where did that freedom go?”
Ali, who has been an American since 2010, was trying to end a seven-year fight
to secure a visa for his daughter. Ali, his w ife, and two other children are
U.S. citizens. But the middle child was born in Yemen and has a Yemeni passport.
The visa process has been hindered by the current civil war in Yemen.
As an example of the “extreme vetting” that already exists, Ali’s daughter
finally got her visa last Thursday. She then began her amazing journey with an
uncle through war-torn Yemen to Jordan. Ali met his daughter and travelled to
Djibouti to board their flight to the U.S., where they could be reunited in
California with their family.
And then Trump signed his executive order.
“It’s kind of more racist and based on religion,” Ali told the Enterprise.
Ali, who works as a convenience store manager, is now stuck abroad. The main
breadwinner for his family, he can’t get back to work. And he can’t go back to
He is like all of us—waiting for the world to come to its senses.
So on this day, let’s remember Ahmed Ali and Fred Korematsu.
History’s echoes are loud and clear.
It’s an urgent call to action as Trump and his xenophobes send America back in
history to relearn a lesson Korematsu should have taught us already.
Emil Guillermo is an independent journalist/commentator. Updates at www.amok.com. Follow Emil on Twitter, and like his Facebook page. The views expressed in his blog do not necessarily represent AALDEF’s views or policies.